Meat Grinder Reviews

Helping You Choose the Right Meat Grinder

Best Meat Grinder Replacement Blades for #5, #8, #12, and #22 Grinders: 9 Picks

Posted on by Colin 19 minutes read

A dull grinder knife can turn a clean batch of meat into a sticky, smeared mess. The cutting blade works against the grinding plate, so a replacement must match the grinder’s size, shaft opening, outside dimensions, and shape. That is why a blade that looks close on a product page may still bind, wobble, or fail to seat correctly.

The main mistake shoppers make is buying by the label alone. A #12 blade is not automatically interchangeable with every #12 grinder, and KitchenAid attachments have several distinct designs. Measure the old blade and drive shaft before ordering, then compare the listed hole size, diagonal length, thickness, material, and model restrictions. Stainless steel is common across these options, but careful cleaning and complete drying still matter for long-term use.

This comparison covers replacement cutting knives in several nominal sizes and model-specific options. Measure the existing blade and check the center opening and manufacturer compatibility before treating a size designation as sufficient.

Quick Answer

  • Best Overall: The four-pack #12 replacement blade offers clearly listed dimensions, four replacement knives, and broad compatibility with standard #12 grinders, though it excludes several proprietary systems.
  • Best for #8 Grinders: The four-pack #8 blade is a practical match for grinders using an approximately 10.5 mm square shaft and 54 mm diagonal blade length.
  • Best for KitchenAid KSMMGA: This blade is specialized for the KSMMGA model only, making it a focused replacement rather than a universal choice.

Best Meat Grinder Replacement Blades Comparison Table

Product Best For Size and Dimensions Pack and Material
Four-Pack #12 Replacement Blades Standard #12 grinders 12.5 mm square hole, 62 mm diameter Four, stainless steel
Two-Pack #12 Replacement Blades Common #12 grinders 12 mm square hole, 61 mm diagonal Two, SS420 stainless steel
Four-Pack #8 Replacement Blades Standard #8 grinders 10.5 mm square hole, 54 mm diagonal Four, stainless steel
Four-Pack Size 5 Blades KitchenAid and size 5 units 8 mm square hole, 48 mm diagonal Four, 420 stainless steel
Mysora FGA Blades Older KitchenAid FGA attachments 1.75-inch blade Two, stainless steel
Two-Pack Size 5 Blades Size 5 and KitchenAid units 8 mm square hole, 48 mm diagonal Two, stainless steel
Mudder Four-Pack Size 5 Blades Size 5 stand mixer attachments 8 mm hole, 48 mm diagonal Four, stainless steel
Two-Pack #22 Blades Most #22 grinders 13 mm square hole, 74 mm diagonal Two, SS420 stainless steel
KSMMGA Replacement Blade KitchenAid KSMMGA only 9.8 mm center hole, 3/16-inch thick One, stainless steel

The reviews below focus on fit, dimensions, pack size, material, cleaning, and the compatibility restrictions that matter before installation.

1. Four-Pack #12 Meat Grinder Blades — Best Overall

4-Pack #12 Meat Grinder Blades

The four-pack #12 replacement knife is the most versatile choice in this group for owners of a standard #12 grinder. Its listed 0.49-inch, or approximately 12.5 mm, square opening and 2.44-inch, or approximately 62 mm, cutting diameter give shoppers useful measurements to compare against an existing blade. That level of detail is valuable because nominal grinder sizes do not guarantee identical blade geometry.

Four blades make sense for people who grind regularly for burgers, meatballs, or sausage and want a clean spare ready after washing the previous knife. The stainless steel construction is described as hardened and rust resistant, but the product remains an aftermarket component. It is specifically excluded from some KitchenAid attachments, LEM #12, and Weston #12 systems, so the broad compatibility claim applies to standard generic equipment rather than every machine carrying a #12 label.

Pros

  • Four-blade pack supports regular replacement and rotation.
  • Lists square-hole, diameter, and thickness measurements.
  • Made from stainless steel for routine food-preparation use.
  • Fits many standard #12 electric and manual grinders when dimensions match.
  • Useful for buyers who want a spare available before a grinding session.

Cons

  • Does not fit several proprietary and branded #12 systems.
  • Requires careful measurement of the original blade and shaft.

This is the sensible starting point for a generic #12 grinder, especially where a four-pack is more useful than a single replacement. It is a poor choice for a KitchenAid attachment or a named LEM or Weston model listed among the exclusions. Wash the cutting surface according to the grinder’s care instructions, dry it fully, and store the blades separately so the edges do not knock against other tools.

To buy this product, click here.

2. Two-Pack #12 Meat Grinder Blades — Best for a Basic #12 Replacement

2 Pcs #12 Meat Grinder Blade Stainless Steel Knife Cutter Replacement

This two-pack targets common size 12 meat grinders and uses SS420 stainless steel. The listed square opening measures 12 mm, with a diagonal length of about 61 mm. Those numbers are close to the four-pack #12 option, but close does not mean interchangeable. A fraction of a millimeter can affect how the blade fits over the drive shaft and meets the grinding plate.

The product listing is unusually direct about exclusions. It identifies KitchenAid sausage makers, LEM #12, Cabela’s #12, Chef’s Choice, Nesco FG-400PR, and the LEM 1224 countertop grinder among systems that should not be treated as compatible. That makes this option better suited to owners of an ordinary, unbranded #12 mincer who have measured the original knife and want two replacements rather than a larger stockpile.

Pros

  • Two replacement knives provide a useful spare.
  • Lists a 12 mm square opening and approximately 61 mm diagonal length.
  • Uses SS420 stainless steel construction.
  • Suitable for many common size 12 grinders when measurements agree.
  • Clearly identifies several incompatible grinder families.

Cons

  • Does not fit the branded models named in the product information.
  • Only a two-pack, which offers less backup than four-piece alternatives.

Choose this blade when your grinder is a generic #12 unit and the old knife matches the listed geometry. The explicit exclusion list is helpful, but it also shows why a model number alone is insufficient. Buyers with an LEM, Cabela’s, or KitchenAid machine should look for a dedicated replacement instead of hoping a nominal size will solve the problem.

To buy this product, click here.

3. Four-Pack #8 Meat Grinder Blades — Best for #8 Grinders

4-Pack #8 Meat Grinder Blades

Size #8 grinders need a smaller knife than #12 machines, and this four-pack provides the relevant dimensions for checking that distinction. The square shaft opening is approximately 10.5 mm, the diagonal length is about 54 mm, and the listed thickness is also around 10.5 mm. Those measurements give a practical checklist for comparing the replacement with the original component before taking the grinder apart.

The stainless steel knife is described as a universal aftermarket part for many common #8 grinders. Installation does not require special tools according to the supplied product information, but correct alignment with the grinding plate remains necessary. A four-pack suits a household that grinds periodically and wants several replacements available, while the smaller #8 format keeps this choice focused on compatible equipment rather than larger grinder heads.

Pros

  • Four-piece pack suits routine replacement needs.
  • Provides square-hole, diagonal-length, and thickness measurements.
  • Designed for many common #8 grinders.
  • Stainless steel construction is suited to normal food preparation.
  • Listed as a tool-free replacement component.

Cons

  • Will not suit #5, #12, or #22 grinder geometry.
  • Universal aftermarket fit still requires measurement confirmation.

This is the strongest dedicated option for a #8 grinder in the supplied selection. It can help restore clean cutting action when the existing knife is worn, but it cannot correct a damaged plate, incorrect assembly, or a mismatched shaft. Clean and dry each blade after use, and keep the original component nearby while checking the dimensions.

To buy this product, click here.

4. Four-Pack Size 5 Meat Grinder Blades — Best for KitchenAid and Size 5 Units

4-Pack Stainless Steel Meat Grinder Blade for Size 5

This four-pack is aimed at size 5 grinders and compatible KitchenAid stand mixer attachments. Its listed 8 mm square opening and 48 mm diagonal length are the key fit measurements. The product information describes 420 stainless steel construction and a four-blade package, which suits a kitchen that moves between burgers, sausage, vegetables, or other compatible foods and wants a replacement ready in the drawer.

Size 5 components are compact, so they are common in home grinder attachments where storage space matters. The compatibility language is broad, but it still calls for a comparison with the existing blade and grinder housing. A KitchenAid attachment owner should confirm the exact attachment design rather than assume every model uses the same knife. The listing also describes dishwasher suitability, although the care instructions for the complete grinder should still take priority.

Pros

  • Four blades provide multiple replacement pieces.
  • Lists the 8 mm square opening and 48 mm diagonal length.
  • Made from 420 stainless steel.
  • Targets size 5 grinders and compatible KitchenAid attachments.
  • Product information describes dishwasher suitability.

Cons

  • Compatibility is limited to matching size 5 geometry.
  • KitchenAid model fit should be checked before purchase.

This package makes the most sense for home cooks who already know they have a matching size 5 attachment. Four pieces reduce the annoyance of discovering a dull knife halfway through holiday meal preparation, but the pack does not make an incompatible attachment compatible. Verify the shaft opening, diagonal measurement, and attachment model before ordering.

To buy this product, click here.

5. Mysora KitchenAid FGA Blades — Best for Older FGA Attachments

Mysora 2 Pack Meat Grinder Blades Compatible with KitchenAid FGA

The Mysora replacement is more specific than a generic size 5 knife. It is intended for older-style KitchenAid FGA food grinder attachments and lists compatibility with part numbers including 4162144, 9706857, W10408733, WPW10408733, 2683750, AP6021041, PS11754361, and 4162143. The blade measures 1.75 by 1.75 inches, giving owners of those older attachments a clearer path than a broad universal listing.

The restriction is equally important. The product information says it does not fit the KSMFGA or newer models. That limitation should be checked before ordering, especially when a stand mixer attachment has been stored for years and its paperwork is missing. Installation is described as a direct swap without special tools. The stainless steel part is intended for meat, vegetables, sausage ingredients, and breadcrumbs, with hand washing in warm soapy water and thorough drying listed for care.

Pros

  • Targets older-style KitchenAid FGA attachments.
  • Lists multiple compatible replacement part numbers.
  • Two-pack provides a spare.
  • Stainless steel construction suits regular kitchen preparation.
  • Direct replacement design does not require special tools.

Cons

  • Not compatible with KSMFGA or newer KitchenAid models.
  • Requires model or part-number verification before purchase.

Choose this blade when the attachment identification matches the listed FGA family. It is a better fit for a known older KitchenAid setup than a generic size 5 knife, but it is the wrong direction for newer equipment. Keep water away from the stand mixer motor housing, and dry the removable blade completely after cleaning.

To buy this product, click here.

6. Two-Pack Size 5 Meat Grinder Blades — Best for a Simple Kitchen Replacement

5# Food Meat Grinder Blade Stainless Steel Knife Cutter

This two-pack uses the familiar size 5 dimensions of an 8 mm square opening and approximately 48 mm diagonal length. The listing identifies compatibility with KitchenAid stand mixers and most size 5 grinders, but it also tells buyers to verify the existing knife’s specifications. That combination makes it a straightforward replacement for a household attachment when the measurements already match.

Stainless steel construction is listed as resistant to rust, and the product information describes dishwasher cleaning or washing with liquid dish soap followed by towel drying. A two-pack is enough for a spare without filling a drawer with extra parts. It is less useful for a buyer who wants four blades for frequent preparation, but it keeps the purchase focused on ordinary home maintenance.

Pros

  • Uses common size 5 dimensions.
  • Two-pack includes a spare replacement.
  • Listed for KitchenAid stand mixers and many size 5 grinders.
  • Stainless steel construction is intended for food preparation.
  • Product information describes dishwasher cleaning.

Cons

  • Requires confirmation that the grinder uses size 5 geometry.
  • Provides fewer replacement blades than the four-packs.

This is a practical pick for occasional burger or sausage preparation with a matching size 5 attachment. It should be skipped when the old blade has a different opening or diagonal measurement, even if the grinder is described as a KitchenAid-compatible model. Measure first, then clean and dry the replacement after installation.

To buy this product, click here.

7. Mudder Four-Pack Size 5 Meat Grinder Blades — Best Four-Pack for Stand Mixer Attachments

Mudder 4 Pack Size 5 Meat Grinder Blade

Mudder’s replacement set is another size 5 option, with an 8 mm hole and 48 mm diagonal length for grinders using a 55 mm housing. The four-piece package is aimed at stand mixer attachments and other size 5 food grinders. Those dimensions closely match the other size 5 choices here, so the practical decision rests on verifying the housing and shaft rather than choosing by the word “universal.”

The stainless steel knives are listed for meat, sausage, and vegetables, with cleaning by dishwasher or liquid dish soap followed by drying. Four pieces are handy for households that prepare several batches across a season, such as burger patties for the freezer followed by sausage on another weekend. The product remains an aftermarket component, and the listing’s instruction to check the grinder model should be treated as a necessary fit test.

Pros

  • Four-piece package supplies several replacements.
  • Lists 8 mm hole and 48 mm diagonal measurements.
  • Targets size 5 stand mixer attachments and 55 mm housings.
  • Stainless steel construction is intended for repeated food preparation.
  • Product information describes dishwasher cleaning.

Cons

  • Very similar dimensions mean careful model checking remains necessary.
  • Does not establish compatibility with every stand mixer attachment.

This set is a reasonable alternative for a measured size 5 attachment where four spares are useful. It should not be selected over a model-specific blade simply because the diameter looks familiar. Compare the original knife, shaft opening, and housing before installation, then keep the cutting edges protected in storage.

To buy this product, click here.

8. Two-Pack #22 Meat Grinder Blades — Best for Larger #22 Grinder Components

2 Pack #22 Meat Grinder Blade Stainless Steel Knife Cutter Replacement

A #22 grinder uses a substantially larger knife than the #5 and #8 parts in this roundup. This replacement lists a 13 mm square opening and a 74 mm diagonal length, with SS420 stainless steel construction. The dimensions give owners of larger grinders a starting point for checking fit, especially when replacing a blade that has become dull or damaged after repeated preparation.

The listing says the knife fits most #22 grinders and may install on a shaft up to 13.5 mm, with tapping mentioned as a possible installation method. That detail calls for caution. A replacement should seat correctly without improvised force, and the buyer should follow the grinder’s assembly requirements rather than treating tapping as a universal instruction. The two-pack provides a spare, but the product is still a non-original aftermarket component.

Pros

  • Designed around #22 grinder dimensions.
  • Lists 13 mm square opening and 74 mm diagonal length.
  • Uses SS420 stainless steel.
  • Two-pack includes a backup blade.
  • Useful for larger grinders that cannot accept smaller knives.

Cons

  • Not suitable for smaller grinder sizes.
  • Installation details require careful shaft and seating checks.

This is the appropriate scale for a compatible #22 grinder, not a general-purpose replacement for home attachments. Buyers should compare the original blade and drive shaft closely and confirm that the cutting edge meets the plate evenly. A larger knife does not automatically mean better results if the grinder’s plate or shaft geometry differs.

To buy this product, click here.

9. KitchenAid KSMMGA Replacement Cutting Blade — Best Model-Specific Fit

New replacement cutting blade for the KitchenAid KSMMGA metal meat grinder

Owners of the KitchenAid KSMMGA face a different task from shoppers seeking a generic #5 or #8 knife. This replacement is identified for the KSMMGA only, with a 2 1/16-inch tip-to-tip measurement, 3/16-inch thickness, and 9.8 mm center hole. The narrow fit claim is its main value because model-specific geometry can matter more than a broad grinder-size label.

The product information repeatedly warns that the blade will not fit other KitchenAid models. The attachment is not included, and the listing identifies the part as non-returnable, so comparing the existing blade with the supplied photos and dimensions is especially important. This is a one-piece replacement rather than a multipack, which suits someone restoring a specific attachment rather than stocking a busy prep station.

Pros

  • Designed specifically for the KitchenAid KSMMGA.
  • Lists tip-to-tip length, thickness, and center-hole dimensions.
  • Stainless steel construction.
  • Useful when a generic size designation is insufficient.
  • Focused model fit can simplify replacement selection for confirmed owners.

Cons

  • Will not fit other KitchenAid meat grinder models.
  • Listed as non-returnable, so measurement checks are critical.

Select this blade only after confirming the attachment is the KSMMGA and the original component matches the listed shape. It is the strongest specialized option here, but its narrow compatibility makes it unsuitable for general replacement shopping. Handle the cutting edge carefully during installation, and keep the attachment disconnected from the mixer while servicing it.

To buy this product, click here.

Buying Guide

Match the Grinder Size Before Comparing Pack Counts

Start with the grinder designation and the old knife. A #5, #8, #12, or #22 label indicates a different component scale, but it does not prove that every replacement within that category shares the same geometry. The #8 option here lists a 10.5 mm square opening, while the #12 choices list openings around 12 to 12.5 mm. Those differences affect installation and alignment.

Measure the Shaft Opening and Blade Length

Use a ruler or caliper to check the square center opening, outside or diagonal length, and thickness where provided. Compare those measurements with the product listing before ordering. A blade can appear identical in a photograph yet fail to slide over the drive shaft or sit flush against the grinding plate. Model numbers help, but physical dimensions are the safer final check.

Distinguish Generic from Model-Specific Compatibility

Universal aftermarket language usually means the knife fits a range of standard grinders, not every branded machine. The four-pack #12 blade excludes several LEM, Weston, and KitchenAid systems. The Mysora blade targets older FGA attachments, while the KSMMGA replacement is limited to one KitchenAid model. Read exclusions as carefully as the compatibility claims.

Choose the Pack Size for Your Routine

A two-pack gives an occasional home user one spare. Four-packs make more sense for frequent grinding, seasonal sausage preparation, or households that prefer rotating clean and used components. A larger pack does not compensate for incorrect fit, so pack quantity should be the final decision after size and compatibility are confirmed.

Check Material and Care Instructions

Most products here use stainless steel, including SS420 or 420 stainless steel on several models. That material supports routine food preparation, but it still deserves careful handling. Some listings describe dishwasher cleaning, while the Mysora product specifies warm soapy water and thorough drying. Follow the instructions attached to the exact blade and never immerse an electric motor housing.

Inspect the Grinding Plate at the Same Time

A cutting knife works with the grinding plate. If the plate is damaged, heavily worn, or mismatched, a new blade may not restore proper cutting action. Check that the replacement sits flat against the plate and that the blade turns without binding before feeding food. Disconnect the grinder or stand mixer while assembling, removing, or cleaning the cutting components.

Best Meat Grinder Replacement Blades FAQ

Can I use any replacement blade marked with the same grinder size?

No. Grinder size is a useful starting point, but shaft opening, diagonal length, thickness, center-hole design, and blade shape can vary. Compare the original component with the listed measurements before ordering.

Are #8 and #12 grinder blades interchangeable?

No. They use different component dimensions. The #8 blade in this roundup lists an approximately 10.5 mm square opening and 54 mm diagonal length, while the #12 choices are larger. Use the blade size intended for the grinder.

Which replacement blade is suitable for a KitchenAid attachment?

That depends on the attachment. The size 5 options target compatible size 5 KitchenAid attachments, the Mysora blade is for older-style FGA units and listed part numbers, and the KSMMGA blade is for the KSMMGA only. Confirm the attachment model before buying.

Does a stainless steel blade need to be dried after washing?

Yes. Stainless steel resists corrosion, but complete drying remains sensible after food preparation. The supplied listings commonly recommend drying, and the Mysora instructions specifically call for washing and thorough drying.

Can a new blade fix meat smearing?

It may help if the original knife is dull or damaged, but smearing can also result from a worn grinding plate, incorrect assembly, unsuitable meat preparation, or a poor fit. Inspect the blade and plate together rather than replacing one component blindly.

Are aftermarket blades safe for every grinder?

No. An aftermarket blade is suitable only when its dimensions and design match the grinder. Several products here list specific exclusions, and the KSMMGA replacement is limited to one model. Do not force a blade that does not seat correctly.

Should I buy a two-pack or four-pack?

Choose a two-pack for occasional household use when one spare is enough. A four-pack is useful for regular grinding, seasonal food preparation, or keeping several clean replacements available. Fit remains more important than quantity.

Final Verdict

The four-pack #12 replacement blade is the best overall choice for a standard #12 grinder because it provides clear measurements, four stainless steel knives, and broad compatibility within the generic #12 category. Its exclusions are significant, though, so owners of LEM, Weston, Cabela’s, or KitchenAid equipment should verify the model before ordering. The two-pack #12 blade is a reasonable alternative for a measured common grinder when fewer spares are needed.

For smaller equipment, the four-pack #8 blade is the focused choice, while the size 5 options serve compact home grinders and compatible stand mixer attachments. Buyers with an older KitchenAid FGA should use the Mysora model-specific replacement, and KSMMGA owners should choose the dedicated KSMMGA blade rather than gamble on a generic knife. Measure the old component, compare the shaft opening and blade length, inspect the grinding plate, and choose the replacement that matches the actual equipment on your counter.

Colin

A meat grinder might seem like a straightforward kitchen appliance, but the details can make a real difference in everyday use. At Meat Grinder Reviews, Colin Mercer explores those details, from grinding capacity and motor design to attachments, cleaning requirements, and long-term upkeep. He takes a practical approach to product comparisons, looking beyond headline specifications to consider where different machines fit best and what compromises buyers should expect.